Friday’s Fast-Food Fishtacular! – SONIC Fish Sandwich

SONIC logo

I don’t know what it is about SONIC. It’s not their prices (not bad, by the way). It’s not their amusing commercials. It’s certainly not their food. Perhaps it’s that SONIC fills the void left by A&W, an American institution that — like the drive-in theater — has largely become a dwindling relic of two generations past.

But I loves me some SONIC.

For years, the closest SONIC was in Anaheim, about 90 miles north on I-5. It was just far enough away to never be a sole reason for a jaunt to the OC, but close enough that we (San Diegans) would see their commercials. A couple years ago, Santee (east of San Diego by a few minutes) got their own SONIC, and by all accounts it’s the most popular thing in that town. Sorry to break the news, Kragen Auto Parts.

I remember having a fish sandwich at the Anaheim SONIC so I drove out to Santee to sample theirs. Thing is, they don’t have it. WHAT? I guess it’s a “specialty” menu item that isn’t universally offered at every drive-in. Well, crap — that’s ONE wasted trip to Santee. But as luck would have it, a couple weeks later I found myself driving to Phoenix and I spotted a SONIC billboard in Yuma, AZ. Camera in hand, low on fuel (both car and my stomach) and making good time, I took the opportunity.

My sandwich experience was fairly mundane, made exciting only by the 20oz. of Cherry Limeade that promised to quench my thirst. The first thing about the sandwich is that it must’ve been fried to order, because A) it took nearly 10 minutes to arrive at the drive-thru window, and B) it was insanely hot. In fact, I popped over to a Circle K, filled up the tank and by time I returned to the sandwich, it was still almost too hot to eat.

Sonic Fish Sandwich nom

And here’s my review: yep, it’s a $2.99 fish sandwich all right.

I wish it was more exciting than that. The fish was good, the tomato was fine (this is high praise from me considering I’m not a person that consumes tomatoes on a regular basis) the bun was soft and the tartar sauce was typical. But that’s what you get at SONIC — average food, awesome drinks and a little bit of modernized mid-20th century nostalgia. Sadly, I did their drive-thru… not even experiencing their rollerskating carhops.

Since I’m reluctant to go back to Yuma for some further research, I jumped online. Like Church’s Chicken, SONIC seems to hide its fish sandwich from its main menu. It was only after downloading SONIC’s full menu .pdf that I found it (under “SNACKS AND SIDES,” which speaks to the gluttony of Americans. “I’ll have a triple SONIC cheeseburger with a side of fish sandwich”). At 650 calories — double that of a Church’s fish sandwich — it’s hardly a “side.”

I guess it’s just as well; if their burgers and fish sandwiches matched the flavor of their drinks and shakes, I’d be road-trippin’ to Santee far too often. Maybe even justifying more road trips to AZ.

Our Man Horn

8 thoughts on “Friday’s Fast-Food Fishtacular! – SONIC Fish Sandwich

Add yours

  1. Hi OMH! I still need to visit a Sonic. Friends tell me not to get too excited but I like trying different fast foods for some strange reason. Glad you found your fish sandwich! 🙂

  2. Weird that Sonic in Santee doesn’t have fish tacos. It proves my theory that they have no taste over there.

  3. My brother-in-law always raves about Sonic in Las Vegas, so once we tried the one in Anaheim. I wasn’t impressed with the burger, and that one didn’t have the carhop on roller skates.

    I’ve only had milkshakes at the Santee Sonic, but should try their food one of these days. Isn’t there a Sonic in Vista now, too?

  4. Chula Vista had a Sonic location waaaaay back in the day. On 3rd ave next to a BK. Maybe 20 years ago? The concept didn’t work and it closed down after a few months.

  5. I miss the A&W and the “A&W” type experience. Years ago, I found an A&W in a mountain town. It was all beat up and pine needles covered the place — Suddenly, I knew what Chuck Heston felt like finding the Statue of Liberty in the Planet of the Apes…

    Perhaps one can blame Man Vs. Food, too, but your post made me want to order a triple burger with a fish sandwich “side.” I imagine the voice on the drive thru saying……”you’re gonna need a bigger boat.”

  6. My local sonic in Southeastern Colorado only serves the Fish Sandwich during the Lent and Easter Season. As I don’t like hamburgers and love fish sandwiches I wait all year for Lent and Easter to come around to have a fish sandwich at Sonic. They use to have it on the menu as a regular item, but several years ago went to just serving it during Lent and Easter. I know I am not the only one that enjoys the Fish Sandwich and I have asked them to bring it back to their regular menu for customers like myself several times so far with no avail.

Leave a Reply to Rachel Grinstead Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: